November 4, 2026
What Does Understanding Opposing Sides of a Criminal Trial Teach Us About the Justice System
By James Record
Having extensive experience in both prosecution and criminal defense, I have had the unique opportunity to be actively involved in the criminal justice system from different professional perspectives. One very interesting fact that has always intrigued me is how criminal trial attorneys, whether prosecutors or criminal defence, can examine the same facts, operate under the same laws, and yet approach a case very differently.
That is not a problem with the system. In fact, it is how the system is designed to work.
Early in my legal career, I served as an Assistant Ocean County Prosecutor. I later worked as a Certified Criminal Trial Attorney, which brought a very different set of legal and ethical responsibilities. The law did not change simply because the role changed, but the approach taken and issues raised certainly did. It was called “switching hats”. You wear the white hat as the prosecutor and the black as the criminal defense attorney.
I think people tend to describe criminal cases as a contest between two sides, each trying to win. While criminal proceedings have an adversarial element, that description leaves out much of what attorneys actually do. Both prosecution and defense require extensive preparation, careful analysis, and an understanding of legal procedure. The difference often comes down to each attorney's legal and ethical responsibilities and how those responsibilities shape their approach to the case.
The Same Case Looks Differently Depending on Your Legal and Ethical Responsibilities.
As a prosecutor, you represent the State/Government. Your responsibility involves evaluating whether the evidence supports criminal charges, determining how the law applies, and presenting the government's case fairly and lawfully. A prosecutor has an obligation not to seek a conviction, but a duty to seek justice. This entails an entirely different set of rules and responsibilities from that of a criminal defence attorney.
Criminal defense involves a very different set of ethical obligations. A defense attorney represents the accused and must protect that person's legal rights and interests to the best of his or her ability. That includes carefully examining the evidence, questioning every government conclusion, identifying any and all possible procedural issues, and ensuring the prosecution meets its burden of proof. A criminal defence attorney’s job is to create reasonable doubt and often entails walking a very fine ethical line.
Having extensive experience working with both of these similar yet very different responsibilities gave me a much broader understanding and appreciation for how criminal cases are evaluated.
Consider a hypothetical case involving a supposed eye witness who allegedly identifies someone after a crime was committed. From the prosecution's perspective, an important question might be whether other evidence supports the identification and whether the identification is reliable. From the defense perspective, the focus includes whether the person is a reliable witness, examining the conditions under which the identification occurred, the possibility of mistaken identification, and whether anything influenced the witness's ability to accurately recollect what he or she allegedly saw.
Both attorneys are looking at the same alleged identification, but they have very different responsibilities when evaluating it.
Understanding that distinction matters because it shows how two sides examining the same evidence can produce different legal issues and arguments. It’s a classic example of critical thinking that is used in the classroom.
Evidence Does Not Interpret Itself
One lesson I took from working both sides of criminal law is that evidence requires much more interpretation and analyzation than people realize.
A witness statement, physical object, or forensic finding may seem convincing on its own. However, the significance of that evidence often depends on circumstances that are not immediately apparent.
If an object is recovered during an investigation, for example, I want to know where it was found, how it was obtained, who handled it, and how it connects to the allegations. Those questions matter regardless of which side of a criminal case an attorney represents.
The difference is in what each attorney needs from that evidence. It may be incriminating or exonerating. It may have been seized under questionable circumstances. Was it somehow contaminated? The list goes on. That is one of the reasons why criminal law and criminal procedure are so interesting to me. The more you examine, the more issues are raised.
A prosecutor examines how the evidence supports the elements of an alleged offense. A defense attorney considers whether the connection is as strong as the prosecution wants it to appear and whether its existence creates reasonable doubt.
Neither approach eliminates the need to examine the evidence completely and understand the law surrounding evidence accurately.
My interest in forensic law has reinforced this point. Scientific evidence can be valuable, but attorneys still need to understand what a particular finding actually establishes and whether it will be admissible at trial. A laboratory result may answer one question while leaving several others unresolved. Understanding those limitations is part of a responsible legal analysis.
Criminal Procedure Is Something Both Sides Have to Understand
Criminal procedure is another area where the ethical and legal responsibilities of prosecution and defense overlap more than people realize.
The rules governing searches, seizures, interrogations, evidence, and constitutional protections apply throughout the criminal justice process. Prosecutors and defence attorneys make legal arguments about how those rules apply to particular facts, but they are working within the same legal framework, whether statutorily or case law.
Take a search conducted during an investigation. A prosecutor needs to evaluate whether the search complied with constitutional requirements and whether the resulting evidence can be introduced in court. A defense attorney examines the same circumstances to determine whether there is a legitimate basis to challenge the search.
Both sides need to understand the law, the relevant facts, and the sequence of events.
I have always found this aspect of criminal procedure particularly interesting because it reminds us that the justice system is about equality for all, not whether there is an acquittal or conviction.
An outcome may seem reasonable to one person but unreasonable to another. This is why the legal process must be followed. Constitutional protections and procedural requirements exist because the government must operate within established limits when investigating and prosecuting criminal matters and criminal defence attorneys must defend those protections and requirements.
Understanding Another Perspective Does Not Mean Necessarily Agreeing With It
One of the most useful lessons from working in different areas of criminal law is learning to recognize the reasoning behind a position without agreeing with the conclusion.
An attorney can understand why the opposing side considers a particular fact important while still believing that the evidence supports a different interpretation.
That ability matters because legal arguments rarely get stronger when we ignore the questions we would rather not answer.
If I am developing an argument, I want to understand what makes the opposing position persuasive. Which facts support it? Which legal principles might apply? Where are the weaknesses in my reasoning?
There is a practical tradeoff involved. Attorneys cannot spend unlimited time examining every possible interpretation of every fact. At some point, decisions must be made, and arguments must be presented. However, reaching a conclusion too quickly creates its own problems.
I would much rather identify a difficult question while preparing than encounter it for the first time when the other side raises it. I never considered myself the best attorney, but I was the most prepared. You never want to be surprised at a trial.
What I Want Criminal Justice Students to Understand
My experience in legal practice has influenced how I think about criminal justice education. After working as an attorney, I moved into higher education, including serving as an Assistant Professor at California University of Pennsylvania. I am also scheduled to join Quincy University as an Associate Professor of Criminal Justice in January 2027.
One thing I want students to understand is that criminal justice cannot be reduced to deciding which side of a case they find more convincing.
Students need to understand the legal and ethical responsibilities of prosecutors, defense attorneys, judges, investigators, and other professionals involved in the process. They also need to recognize that those responsibilities influence which questions are asked and how information is evaluated.
When discussing a hypothetical criminal case, I think it is useful to consider how the analysis might change depending on the professional role involved. What would a prosecutor need to establish? What would defense counsel need to examine? What procedural questions might concern both sides?
The goal is not to suggest that every argument is equally strong. It is to help students develop the ability to evaluate competing positions before reaching a conclusion. That is critical thinking.
Different Responsibilities Within the Same System
Looking back at my experience in prosecution and criminal defense, I do not think the most important lesson is that one side sees criminal justice more clearly than the other.
Each role carries responsibilities that shape how an attorney approaches a case. Those differences are meaningful, but they exist within a shared legal framework built around evidence, procedure, constitutional protections, and the burden of proof.
I also think experience in one role makes someone more attentive to the questions raised by another. Understanding how an opposing argument develops encourages better preparation and a more careful examination of the entire case.
That does not mean disagreements disappear. In most cases, just the opposite. Prosecutors and defense attorneys examine the same evidence and often reach very different conclusions. The important question is whether through proper preparation, you can argue that your conclusions are supported by the facts and the law and thus more persuasive to the judge and jury. For me, working in different areas of criminal law has reinforced the importance of looking beyond a single interpretation. It has also influenced what I hope students take away from studying criminal justice.
Understanding the system requires more than knowing the rules. It requires understanding the people who apply them, the obligations they carry, and why different perspectives deserve careful examination.
I have continued to appreciate that throughout my career as an attorney and educator.